Impossible Predictions Becoming Possible

By CIRCulator Editorial Staff

Reprinted from: The Climate CIRCulator

A thermometer at 115 degrees
“Thermometer 115” (Photo: Conservation Law Foundation, Some Rights Reserved.)

THE ACCURACY OF WEATHER FORECASTS declines sharply after about five to eight days. Beyond 10 days you may as well just use the averages taken from the meteorological record for the dates you are interested in, meaning you might as well ditch weather forecasting altogether and turn to climatology. But in some circumstances, specific types of weather might be predicted weeks in advance.

Writing in Nature Geoscience, Karen McKinnon of the National Center for Atmospheric Research and her colleagues found that some heat events in the eastern U.S. are predictable by as much as 50 days in advance. (In their paper, the researchers define heat events as at least two successive days above the 95th percentile over the eastern US.) The researchers arrived at this discovery after identifying statistically significant relationships between a temperature pattern in the Pacific Ocean, what they call the “Pacific Extreme Pattern,” and heat events as much as 50 days later over roughly the eastern third of the continental U.S.

The breakthrough in McKinnon and colleagues’ approach is how it fills a gap between weather forecasts and seasonal climate forecasts.

Weather forecasting primarily relies on knowing the exact state of the atmosphere at the time of the forecast. Because the exact state of the atmosphere is hard to know, and small errors accumulate into big errors over time, weather forecasts lose accuracy in a matter of days. Seasonal climate forecasts, on the other hand, primarily use the state of the tropical Pacific, which unfolds slowly; they do not rely at all on knowing the state of the atmosphere. Like seasonal climate forecasts, the researchers’ approach works because the information comes from the slowly unfolding ocean.

The mechanism connecting the Pacific Ocean to the eastern U.S. discovered by the researchers is a pattern of slowly evolving atmospheric disturbances that gradually result in a strong ridge over the target area. While this paper only looked at heat events in the eastern U.S., in our view the same mechanism noted by the researchers should also lead to long-lead predictions of heat events in the Northwest. Similar research points to this possibility.

In 2003, University of Washington’s Nick Bond (now Washington State Climatologist) and Gabe Vecchi (now with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) showed that Northwest precipitation and the likelihood of flooding could be linked to a tropical phenomenon called the Madden-Julian Oscillation. In their paper, McKinnon and colleagues also note that when the previous 30 days had been unusually dry, heat events were more likely to occur within the next 40 days.

The reason is simple. It’s long been known that if the ground is dry, the same amount of radiative heating coming from the sun and the atmosphere can warm the ground and the air faster than if the ground is wet. When the ground is wet, some of that heat energy goes to evaporating the water. In short, the ground can sweat, keeping it cooler.

Note: Lead author Karen McKinnon has a link to OCCRI. McKinnon was a NOAA Hollings Fellow (summer intern) with OCCRI Director Phil Mote at the University of Washington in summer 2009 working on

Citation: McKinnon, K. A., A. Rhines, M. P. Tingley, and P. Huybers. “Long-lead predictions of eastern United States hot days from Pacific sea surface temperatures.” Nature Geoscience (2016). DOI: 10.1038/NGEO2687


1 comments on "Impossible Predictions Becoming Possible"
  1. But hope springs eternal…and so we look for the 7-day forecast, even demand it from meteorologists who know too well how little value they are giving us. Informative post!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *